|Abstract Title:||Validation of fugitive methane fluxes using unmanned aerial vehicles|
|Session Choice:||Current capabilities and case studies|
|Presenter Name:||Dr Grant Allen|
|Co-authors:||Mr Mark Bourn|
Dr Rod Robinson
Dr Jon Helmore
Dr Paul Williams
Dr Peter Hollingsworth
|Company/Organisation:||University of Manchester|
Abstract Information :
We present a case study of a validation experiment to characterise the precision and uncertainty constraints of a newly developed mass balancing flux calculation method, using in situ measurements of methane concentration sampled by an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) platform.
This case study (funded by the UK Environment Agency) was conducted by the University of Manchester and National Physical Laboratory with assistance from the UK Met Office at its Cardington research facility. The aim of the work was to validate an adapted form of the conventional mass balancing approach to flux calculation, tailored for UAV platform sampling of methane concentrations and local wind measurement. Our approach consisted of 7 UAV flights around 500 m downwind of a known methane release facility (operated by NPL), where a range of methane flux rates were released in a blind exercise. Fluxes were calculated from downwind sampling by a rotary UAV and tethered high-precision methane sensor (Los Gatos Research UGGA cavity ringdown spectrometer) and later compared with calibrated flux release data after UAV fluxes had been calculated to ensure a blind exercise (administered by the UK Environment Agency).
The results of the validation demonstrate that the method can retrieve fugitive flux to within a 10% root-mean-square bias (across 7 flights, representing ˜2 hours of sampling) with typical uncertainty of less than 40% over one flight (representing 17 minutes of UAV sampling) at ambient concentrations similar to elevations seen around UK landfills in moderate prevailing winds (< 5 m/s). Sensitivity to background and wind variability over the course of sampling were found to dominate the relative uncertainty as propagated in the mass balance flux algorithm. Future developments in UAV 3D wind measurement and onboard high-precision methane measurement may serve to reduce such error components further.
This newly validated method offers a new technology (and technique) through which industrial facility-level methane fugitive flux can be accurately and traceably quantified in case study (snapshot) approaches. Moreover, routine UAV sampling can help to monitor emissions and detect hazardous leaks quickly over a wide area, taking advantage of the portability of UAVs and their ability to safely access hazardous environments (e.g. areas of suspected strong methane leaks)